As someone who has worked in the exterior remodeling industry, I’ve heard so many conversations with homeowners about their roofing projects. One of the most common mistakes I see is choosing the cheapest roofing estimate. I get it—saving money is important. But when it comes to your roof, the lowest bid often leads to the highest long-term costs.
Let me explain why cutting corners on a roofing project can end up being a costly mistake, and what I always tell homeowners to look for instead.
The True Cost of a Cheap Roof
I’ve seen it time and time again—homeowners choose a low bid, thinking they’re getting a great deal, only to call us a few years later with leaks, missing shingles, or worse, structural damage. Here’s what usually goes wrong with those “too-good-to-be-true” quotes:
- Inferior Materials – Many low-cost contractors use subpar shingles, cheap underlayment, and flimsy flashing that won’t hold up against Wisconsin’s harsh winters.
- Poor Workmanship – Roofing is a skilled trade, and inexperienced or rushed labor leads to improper installations, voided warranties, and premature failures.
- No Warranty Protection – Some of the cheapest bids come from contractors who don’t stand behind their work. If your roof fails, you’re on your own.
- Hidden Costs – That cheap estimate may not include proper ventilation, flashing replacement, or tear-off costs—meaning you’ll pay more later.
I’ve talked to homeowners who had to replace their roof twice in a decade because they went with a cut-rate contractor. That’s why I always tell people: invest in quality the first time.
What to Look for in a Roofing Contractor
If you’re comparing estimates, don’t just look at the price. Here are the key things I recommend checking before signing any contract:
- Is the contractor licensed and insured? – A reputable company like Infinity Exteriors will provide proof of both.
- What materials are being used? – Ask about the brand and quality of shingles, underlayment, and ventilation.
- Are they offering a manufacturer-backed warranty? – A good roofing system should come with both material and workmanship warranties. Once again, Infinity Exteriors crushes it! 🙂
- What do their past customers say? – Online reviews, testimonials, and project photos can tell you a lot about their work.
- Are they local and established? – Out-of-town contractors may disappear after storm season, leaving you with no recourse if problems arise.
At Infinity Exteriors, we take pride in offering fair pricing without compromising on quality. We aren’t the cheapest option—but we are saving our communities from unscrupulous contractors.
The Bottom Line
Your roof is one of the most important investments you’ll ever make in your home. A cheap estimate may save you money today, but it can cost you thousands in repairs, early replacement, or even damage to your home’s structure.
So, when you’re comparing roofing bids, don’t just ask, “How much does it cost?” Ask, “What am I really getting for my money?”
If you want a roof built to last, let’s talk. At Infinity Exteriors, we offer transparent pricing, top-quality materials, and workmanship you can trust. Contact us today for a free estimate.